Menu
Tenant Screening
Tenant Screening
Tenant Screening

Tenant Screening and Qualification

You can have a beautiful property in a prime location, but if you place the wrong tenant, it doesn’t take long for problems to pile up. 3 Options Realty makes screening a top priority for every rental we manage. Quality screening protects your investment and sets the tone for a positive rental relationship from the start. Read more to find out why tenant screening in Atlanta, Georgia, is so important and how working with a professional can give you a major advantage. 

Why Thorough Screening Matters

It only takes one bad tenant to rack up thousands of dollars in unpaid rent, property damage, and legal fees. Many landlords underestimate the financial risk until it’s too late. A solid screening process looks at income, verifies employment, checks credit history, reviews the rental background, and examines any past evictions or legal issues. Strong screenings are a must because the rental market here moves fast, and bad tenants know how to slip through rushed processes. Without the right system in place, it’s easy to overlook details that could come back to haunt you. 3 Options Realty uses a proven screening service to make sure our property owners have the best protection possible.

Reviews

5

Three Options has managed my investment homes for over for 5 years. They have been great to work with and I highly recommend Three options realty. Thank you three options realty for taking care of my houses and me!

Customer

Roswell, GA
5

I would like to give a shoutout to 3 Options Realty for being so awesome The transformation for moving into the home was so easy with their guidance on everything, they were the best at it all! If you want someone that is caring and on top of everything three options Realty is the one. Once again thank you 3 Options. I love the home I'm in.

Customer

Roswell, GA
5

We were so fortunate in choosing Brenna to sell my mom's home.  She went through the house and made suggestions as to where we should make updates, that were not overly expensive, but that greatly enhanced the home.  These updates made it possible to get top dollar. We had multiple offers within 3 days of listing.  She is available 24/7 and is on top of everything in the process to provide a smooth, quick transaction.

Cathy

Roswell, GA
5

Dealing with Dan has been a very good experience. He brings personalization and total involvement and carefulness to the process. He dots all the I's and makes sure the T's are crossed. He also brings a wealth of quality personal experience from both the sales and buying sides. Great to have on your team!

Glen

Marietta, Georgia
5

Several years ago Dan helped us look for a lakefront home on Lake Lanier. Dan did his research and showed us many interesting properties, spending many hours with us viewing each of the choices. Dan also helped us in the sale of our home in Roswell, as well with property management for a friend's townhouse that we referred to him.

Ray and Judy Muscari

Cumming, Georgia
Tenant Screening

Red Flags That Warn of a Risky Tenant

Knowing what to look for during the application process can save you a lot of trouble. Here are some common red flags that likely mean a prospective tenant might not be the right fit:

  •  Incomplete Applications: If someone doesn’t fully complete the application or leaves major sections blank, it’s usually a warning sign that they’re trying to hide something.
  • Eviction History: A previous eviction, especially for nonpayment of rent or damaging property, should always be taken seriously.
  • Unverifiable Income or Employment: A tenant who cannot prove steady employment or a legitimate source of income is a major risk.
  • Poor Credit History: While not every tenant needs perfect credit, serious patterns of debt, collections, or bankruptcies can predict payment problems.
  • Frequent Moves: Someone who jumps from one rental to another without good reason may not be planning to stay long-term.

Mistakes Landlords Make When Screening Alone

Tenant screening is not as simple as running a credit report and calling it a day. Many landlords who handle it themselves make mistakes that leave them exposed to unnecessary risk. Here are some of the biggest missteps:

  • Skipping the Background Check: Some landlords rely solely on a "gut feeling" after meeting a potential tenant. This is a costly gamble.
  • Inconsistent Standards: Without clear criteria, landlords may approve tenants inconsistently and open themselves up to claims of discrimination.
  • Poor Verification Practices: It's not enough to accept pay stubs or landlord references at face value. Fake documents and friends posing as previous landlords are more common than you think.
  • Moving Too Fast: In a rush to fill a vacancy, landlords sometimes cut corners and approve a tenant without doing a full check. This almost always backfires.

What Professional Property Management Companies Review in Applications

A screening service involves looking at several factors to get the full picture of a candidate's reliability. Here’s what professional property managers review during the application process:

Our Services

  • Rent Disbursement

    Rent Disbursement

    Getting paid should be the easy part, but when you're a property owner, making sure your rental proceeds land in your…

    Read More
  • Guarantees

    Guarantees

    3 Options Realty is committed to providing Georgia's best property management services. But in the unlikely event that a landlord…

    Read More
  • Property Management

    Property Management

    Are you struggling to maintain multiple rental properties? Have you recently purchased your first real estate investment, but are feeling overwhelmed…

    Read More
  • Leasing & Management

    Leasing & Management

    When you manage a rental property, you have to find tenants, collect rent, and fix structural issues when they arise. What…

    Read More
  • Income Verification: Tenants should have a minimum income-to-rent ratio to make sure they can comfortably afford the property.
  • Employment History: Stability matters. We verify employment length and type to gauge long-term prospects.
  • Credit Report Analysis: We look for patterns like consistent late payments, charged-off accounts, or excessive debts.
  • Criminal Background Check: A detailed check for serious criminal activity helps protect the safety of the property and neighborhood.
  • Rental History Verification: We contact previous landlords to ask specific questions about payment history, property care, and tenant behavior.
  • Personal References: These help provide additional insight into the applicant’s character and reliability.

Do You Need Help Checking Tenant Qualifications?

Finding the right tenant is the reward of careful preparation and smart systems. If you’re concerned about checking tenant qualifications properly or you need help taking care of tenant screening in Atlanta, Georgia, 3 Options Realty is ready to help. Contact us to schedule a consultation when you’re ready to protect your investment and enjoy the benefits of reliable property management services

Our proprietary tenant qualification process helps assure the best home rental experience for both landlords and tenants. This page outlines the principles underlying our process and is intended to help both renters and property owners better understand the screening process.

Fair Housing:
First and foremost it is important for both landlord clients and any tenant prospects that make application to rent homes listed by 3 Options Realty, to understand that we fully support and comply with federal and state fair housing laws and rules.  We will never deny an applicant on the basis of their race, color, national origin, handicap, sex, marital status, sexual preference, or gender identity. 

Mitigating Risk: 
Landlords gather personal information in the application process for the sole purpose of determining whether or not a tenant prospect is a good risk. Each landlord may approach this process a little differently, but one aspect seems universal—the landlord wants to gain a reasonable assurance that the tenant will take care of the property, and pay rent on time. It’s really that simple, but the question might then be: What does the landlord want to see, or not see, to make this determination.

History of Financial Affairs:
It is not the “financial picture” of the prospect at the time of application, but rather more about the “financial movie”, or the story, that got them there.  Most important is demonstrated behavior over the most recent few years. For example, an applicant that had once cleaned up a poor credit situation may not be favorably considered because the applicant’s recent history indicates continued and repetitive poor money judgment. So, while it is good that the applicant has overcome the problems of the past, the landlord still may not be comfortable, because evidence of new good habits has either not had time to be proved or has continued to be negative.

Qualification Sources of Information:
Most landlords will look at recent rental history, and job stability. Professional property managers will also look at credit history, and some will even look at criminal background.

Veracity of the Applicant:
Landlords want to see that the prospect is truthful in the application. Therefore, information given on an application will be checked against the responses from past landlords, employers, and the credit report.  A skilled landlord can quickly detect fabricated stories, and such may invariably lead to application denial.

Qualification Criteria:
Qualifying criteria can be widely and diversely applied by different landlords. The fundamental concepts are offered below:

Past Rental stability:
How long has the tenant lived at the same address? Usually, the longer the tenant has lived at the same address the better.

Past landlord reference:
Did the past landlord give a favorable referral? Questions commonly asked of them are: Did the tenant give proper termination notice? Did the tenant get all of the security deposit back? Did the tenant make timely rental payments? Did the tenant tender any or many checks written with nonsufficient funds?

Rental History:
How much has the tenant been paying for rent? Is current rent about the same as the proposed rent, or at least a sensible and justifiable increase based on other financial factors?

Employment:
How long has the tenant worked for the same employer or in the same career field? The longer a tenant prospect has been employed by the same employer the better.

Rent to Income Ratio: 
What percentage of total income is the rent payment (rent divided by net income)? The lower this percentage the better, but most landlords are uncomfortable when this number is greater than 33%.

Credit Score:
Some landlords are concerned with a prospect’s credit score. The only way to know what number the landlord is looking for is to ask that question of the landlord. It is debatable as to the value of this metric for rental application purposes. While is frequently used in this process by professional property managers, 3 Options Realty does not consider it at all. Rather, a decision is made based upon other factors combined.  

Credit History:
While rent is not considered a debt (or credit), the credit report can be very telling about the applicant’s demonstrated money-management discipline. Often times, landlords will simply disqualify a prospect based solely on how poorly they have managed debt. Opinions vary widely across the industry about these criteria. The following are the categories most often weighed, although no single one of them will be grounds for disapproval by 3 Options Realty, Property Managers:

Capacity:
How much of the applicant’s approved credit has been consumed? This is an indicator of the prospect’s money-management skill and discipline. Anything above 50% may cause a landlord to become wary—the higher this number, the greater the indication that such applicants may be living irresponsibly above their means.

Delinquencies:
The landlord’s interest is in the number and frequency of credit lines paid late. Late mortgage and rental payments might be an automatic disqualifier for many landlords.

Derogatory information:
Charge-offs and collections will be weighed heavily against the applicant.

Court Judgments and Liens:
These will be automatic disqualifiers for many landlords, especially if a judgment is recent and is for past due rent.

Foreclosures:
Sometimes the story behind the event will help the property manager deal with this issue, but this can be a deal killer for many.

Discharged Bankruptcy:
Some landlords will automatically deny the applicant for simply having a bankruptcy appear on their record. Others may ask about the circumstances leading up to the event. If the answer is about a financial situation that got out of control, but not directly due to the applicant’s behavior (such as high medical bills), the adverse affect may be somewhat mitigated.

Dismissed Bankruptcy:
This may be considered by many landlords to be a more serious derogatory than a discharged bankruptcy, because it illustrates an unfavorable money management attitude—one that the courts did not accept.

Criminal Background:
Most landlords are uncomfortable renting to convicted felons. However, if a lot of time has passed since incarceration, and the other qualifying criteria are otherwise favorable, this derogatory circumstance might be overcome.  Our criteria for this category is any felon that has served a prison sentence for a period of one year or greater.


Courses of action for concerned tenant applicants:

Fix the Problem:
Whatever shortfalls you may have in your current financial situation—work on improving them. Do not ignore or try to minimize them. Do not make excuses for them. They are a real part of your financial landscape. So recognize them. Understand the debilitating affect they have on your financial history.  Fix the problems, learn from them, and move on.

CAUTION:
Credit repair companies and debt consolidators can sound convincing about their ability to help you clean up your credit, but in reality and in many cases, these outfits are fraudulent or at least disingenuous, and will only put you deeper in debt in financial obligation to them. The National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC) is a legitimate resource. They make no promises, but they can help guide you through the credit repair process.   

Letter of Explanation:
For many of the reasons listed above, if an applicant’s qualification is questionable, the applicant can make a big difference by preparing a letter to submit along with the application explaining the circumstances relating to the incriminating information. Again, don’t make excuses. Rather, truthfully explain how and why things happened, and further explain what you are doing or have done to address the issues. Take responsibility for your past behavior. Carefully and thoughtfully prepare this letter. Have someone edit it for grammar. If you are not a good writer, ask someone who is a good writer to compose it for you. This letter could make all the difference in the approval or denial of your application.  

Referrals:
Don’t be shy about asking your employer and your landlord for written references. If they are willing, enclose these references with your rental application. This will go a long way towards securing approval.

Latest News & Blogs
01
May
Property Manager Skills: What to Look for in a Property Manager

Rental property ownership comes with a multitude of responsibilities that can be overwhelming if tackled alone. With that said, hiring…

Read More
01
May
How to Rent a Furnished Apartment That’s Right for You?

Furnished apartments are popular options for short-term renters. Whether it is a temporary move, a short job, or you just need…

Read More
01
May
Eight Pro Tips to Refine Your Move-Out Process

When a lease is terminated, regardless of the reason, it sets in motion a move-out process. This is often overwhelming for…

Read More
01
May
Advantages of Hiring a Professional Property Management Company

Are you a rental property owner? Do you wish to be relieved of the many responsibilities that come with ownership without…

Read More