The Pros and Cons of Tenants Doing Maintenance
The Pros and Cons of Tenants Doing Maintenance

Sep 19,2023

The Pros and Cons of Tenants Doing Maintenance

Renting out a property comes with its challenges and responsibilities for landlords. One aspect of property management that often arises is tenants offering to perform maintenance tasks. While it may seem like a win-win situation—landlords save money, and tenants get quick repairs. However, delving deeper reveals a hidden motive. At 3 Options Realty, we understand the dilemma of handling maintenance or letting tenants cover the cost. We recommend hiring professional property managers to handle the heavy lifting. Here are the pros and cons of tenants taking on maintenance responsibilities.

The Pros

  • Cost Savings

The most apparent benefit of having tenants handle maintenance tasks is the potential cost savings for landlords. Instead of hiring professional contractors, landlords can rely on the skills and labor of their tenants, which can translate into lower expenses.

  • Quick Repairs

When tenants are willing and capable of performing maintenance, repairs can be completed quickly. This can lead to increased tenant satisfaction, as issues are resolved on time.

  • Tenant Satisfaction

Tenants involved in the upkeep of their living spaces may feel a stronger sense of ownership and investment in the property. This can lead to increased pride in the property and a better overall rental experience.

  • Reduced Vacancy

Happy tenants are likely to renew their leases. By promptly addressing maintenance issues, landlords can improve tenant satisfaction and reduce turnover, leading to reduced vacancy rates and consistent rental income.

The Cons

  • Quality and Reliability

While some tenants may possess the proper skills to handle maintenance tasks competently, others may need to. Landlords risk subpar workmanship or incomplete repairs, which could lead to more significant problems. The best way to avoid such scenarios is to hire a trusted property management company. We recommend certified technicians to handle maintenance without breaking the bank or compromising quality.

  • Liability Issues

Allowing tenants to perform maintenance tasks can raise liability concerns. The landlord may be held responsible if a tenant injures themselves while attempting repairs. In addition, if the tenant’s work causes damage to the property or exacerbates existing issues, it could cause costly repairs. A professional property management company can minimize liability issues by drafting a lease agreement stipulating who should handle maintenance.

  • Legal and Regulatory Compliance

Depending on local laws and regulations, there may be restrictions on tenants performing maintenance tasks. Landlords must comply with all relevant legal requirements to avoid potential legal issues. If you want to avoid expensive penalties or legal action, hire a professional to handle maintenance. As mentioned, our property managers work with certified technicians, ensuring maintenance projects comply with local laws.

While the idea of tenants performing maintenance may initially seem appealing, it comes with pros and cons that landlords must carefully consider. Cost savings and tenant satisfaction are potential benefits, but they must be weighed against the risks of subpar workmanship, liability issues, and conflicts of interest. Contact 3 Options Realty to establish clear policies and prioritize your properties’ and tenants’ safety and well-being.

Recent Blogs

Jun 20,2024
Telltale Signs Your House Will…

Are you a homeowner with extra room that can…

Read More
Jun 15,2024
What to Do When Your…

Managing rental properties is daunting, especially when tenants fail…

Read More
Jun 06,2024
How to Finance an Investment…

Investing in real estate can be lucrative, but financing…

Read More

Landlord Options

Owner Portal

In appreciation for your continued patronage, we are pleased to offer you a management fee rebate equal to 2 months of management fees for any…

Read More
Leasing & Management

If you are interested in professional property management services, you probably have some questions about the process and we have a few questions we…

Read More
Rent Disbursement

Standard Rental Proceeds Disbursement Policy. It is the standard policy of 3 Options Realty to disburse monthly rental proceeds to property owners between the 15th…

Read More

We Are Ready to
Take Your Call


If you have been rummaging through web results for “property management companies near me,” then you are at the right place. 3 Options Realty’s property managers in Atlanta are experienced and trained to deliver top-tier service. Call 3 Options Realty to speak with a friendly representative today to learn more about our property management & real estate services. We are ready to take your call.

Buy, Sell & Rent with 3 Options Realty


We use professional market research to determine fair-market rent, and we use broad market advertising to reach a large audience. Our agents will also help you prepare your property and skillfully present your property. Prospective tenants will undergo comprehensive interviews and background screening before we negotiate with them the rental agreement using our proprietary, attorney-reviewed forms.